Jack from Quality 1st came by and immediately identify the source of the water issue was NOT from the foundation but most likely due to a leak in the outdoor bib. Opened the wall and there it was, water leaking from the shark bite connector.
A few days ago, another contractor came and looked at the same problem and immediately quoted $3500 to install a drainpipe with no mentioning of the potential leaking issue. I think it's fair to say which business is more honest.
Can't comment on how good a job Quality 1st basement is doing, but at least I know they're not going to charge me something I don't need.
Quality 1st came recommended by my sister who is hard to please.